Why Zelenskyy Is Wrong About Putin Abandoning The Rules Of War

Why Zelenskyy Is Wrong About Putin Abandoning The Rules Of War

We love our simple morality plays. The narrative machine feeds us a steady diet of absolute villains throwing away every baseline of human decency, painting total war as an anarchic free-for-all where all historical constraints burn to ash. When Volodymyr Zelenskyy steps to a microphone and declares that Moscow has entirely abandoned the rules of engagement, Western newsrooms race to echo the line. It fits the emotional architecture of a besieged nation fighting for survival.

It is also strategically lazy and analytically bankrupt.

Wars do not descend into lawless chaos because a dictator wakes up angry. Modern military operations, even the most brutal territorial invasions of the twenty-first century, remain bound by a grim, calculated calculus of utility, logistics, and escalation management. When commentators buy into the trope that the Kremlin has thrown out the rulebook entirely, they miss the terrifying reality: the Russian military is not abandoning the rules of war. They are operating under a different, hyper-cynical set of constraints that we refuse to study because calling it pure madness is easier than decoding the mechanics.

I have spent decades watching analysts mistake doctrine they dislike for a lack of doctrine altogether. That intellectual laziness gets people killed.

Let us dismantle the comforting fiction that Moscow has torn up the Geneva Conventions in a fit of feral lawlessness, and look at the functional reality governing the current theater of conflict.

The Myth of Complete Anarchy

To claim someone has abandoned the rules implies there was a mutual agreement to uphold them in the first place, or that survival depends on signaling adherence to an international tribunal. That is not how great power competition works.

When international organizations throw their hands up and accuse the Kremlin of throwing away restraint, they are applying the framework of legalistic Western jurisprudence to a state security apparatus that views international law as a diplomatic speed bump. Moscow does not operate in a vacuum of random violence. Every missile strike against civilian infrastructure, every forced deportation, and every scorched-earth artillery barrage follows an operational logic. It is a logic rooted in Soviet deep battle theory, updated for the electronic age, designed to break the psychological will of a civilian population until the political cost of resistance outweighs the cost of capitulation.

Calling this a complete breakdown of military order misses the point. It is a structured, systematic doctrine of coercive punishment. If we pretend it is just mindless barbarism, we fail to build the countermeasures required to blunt it.

Popular Narrative vs. Operational Reality

Popular Narrative:
- Total lawlessness and random destruction
- Emotional outbursts driving military tactics
- Complete abandonment of operational strategy

Operational Reality:
- Calculated doctrine of coercive pressure
- Systematic targeting designed to break societal resilience
- Strategic calculus balancing domestic and international blowback

The Utility of Controlled Atrocity

Let us talk about why the lazy consensus is dangerous. If you believe your adversary has gone feral, your response defaults to moral outrage and endless appeals to a nonexistent global conscience. You plead for international intervention on humanitarian grounds while your adversary continues to exploit the precise seams between legal warfare and strategic terror.

The harsh truth is that modern total war has always blurred these lines. Every major military power in history, including the architects of the liberal international order, has pushed the envelope of what constitutes legitimate military necessity when existence is on the line. To pretend that Moscow is uniquely divorced from the historical evolution of industrial warfare is historical illiteracy.

When civilian infrastructure like the power grid is systematically dismantled as winter approaches, Western pundits shriek about a total disregard for the laws of armed conflict. From a purely cynical Clausewitzian perspective, however, disconnecting a nation's heating and communications network is an extension of warfare by other means: targeting the industrial and psychological capacity to sustain a prolonged mobilization. It is a horrific calculation, but it is a calculation nonetheless. It is bound by resources, fuel supplies, missile stockpiles, and the fear of triggering direct NATO involvement.

That is not the behavior of an army with no rules. That is the behavior of an army playing a different game with higher risk tolerances.

Redefining the Calculus of Escalation

We must also look at the feedback loop on the other side. Kyiv benefits immensely from framing the adversary as a monstrous outlaw. It solidifies international coalitions, greases the wheels for billions in military aid, and keeps global public opinion locked into a binary of absolute good versus absolute evil. Diplomacy thrives on shades of grey, but total war thrives on stark black and white.

Yet, when you convince your own population and your allies that the enemy follows no rules, you box yourself into a strategic corner. If the adversary is inherently incapable of adhering to norms, then negotiations become conceptually impossible. You cannot parley with a force of nature. You can only crush it completely.

Imagine a scenario where the conflict grinds into a permanent stalemate because neither side can achieve total military victory. If our entire baseline is built on the premise that the other side is entirely lawless, any future peace settlement becomes politically radioactive. How do you sign a treaty with a state you have spent years defining as a total negation of civilization itself?

This is the trap of moral absolutism in foreign policy. It wins the news cycle today, but it forecloses the political exits tomorrow.

The Cost of Refusing to See the Machine

We must confront the mechanics of how military force actually scales in the twenty-first century. No army can maintain absolute brutality across an entire front indefinitely without collapsing its own logistical and economic infrastructure. The sanctions, the manpower shortages, the internal political friction within the Kremlin—these are the real boundaries of Russian operations. They are not checked by the spirit of international law; they are checked by hard power limits and the fear of domestic instability.

When we pretend that the rules of war are magical spells that protect the innocent if only everyone believes hard enough, we infantilize our understanding of geopolitics. The rules only hold weight when the penalty for breaking them exceeds the strategic benefit. When a nation decides that its survival as an imperial project is on the line, international treaties become scraps of paper. Every serious strategist knows this. Pretending otherwise is a luxury reserved for editorial boards far from the front lines.

The frontline soldier does not care about the legal classification of an incoming shell. They care about the trajectory, the warning time, and the counter-battery fire. Analysts sitting in comfortable capital cities should adopt the same hard-nosed realism.

Stop looking at the conflict through the lens of a courtroom drama. Start looking at it as a cold, grinding engine of industrial attrition where every action, no matter how abhorrent, is weighed against its utility on the chessboard.

Until we understand the actual rules they are playing by, we will keep losing the intellectual war long before the shooting stops.

EC

Emily Collins

An enthusiastic storyteller, Emily Collins captures the human element behind every headline, giving voice to perspectives often overlooked by mainstream media.