Why Indonesia keeps burning and choking the region in smoke

Why Indonesia keeps burning and choking the region in smoke

Every few years, the skies over Southeast Asia turn a sickly, bruised orange. The air thickens until it tastes like a campfire mixed with exhaust fumes. Schools shut down, flights get canceled, and millions of people reach for N95 masks while emergency rooms fill up with patients gasping for breath. The blame immediately falls on Indonesia, and honestly, the finger-pointing is fair.

Indonesia remains the epicenter of an annual ecological disaster that sends toxic haze drifting across borders into Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei. But if you think this is simply a matter of careless farmers striking a few matches, you are missing the entire economic engine driving the destruction.

Let's look at what is actually happening on the ground.

The underground monster nobody sees

The main reason these fires defy containment isn't a lack of water or manpower. It is the dirt.

Much of the agricultural expansion in places like Sumatra and Kalimantan takes place on tropical peatlands. Peat is basically ancient, partially decayed plant matter that has accumulated over thousands of years in waterlogged, swampy conditions. Think of it as a massive, soggy sponge made of carbon.

When developers drain these swamps to plant lucrative crops, that wet sponge dries out. It turns into dry tinder.

Once fire hits drained peat, standard firefighting tactics fail completely. You can pour millions of liters of water on the surface, and the flames will simply vanish for a few hours before burrowing underground. They smolder silently out of reach, chewing through layers of dense carbon meters beneath the topsoil. They release thick plumes of carbon monoxide, methane, and particulate matter into the atmosphere for weeks or months.

Rain doesn't even put them out. Only heavy, sustained monsoons or massive saturation efforts can drown out these subsurface furnaces. Until Indonesia restores the hydrology of these drained swamps, the fires will keep coming back.

Follow the palm oil money

You cannot understand the haze crisis without looking at cash flow.

For decades, global demand for palm oil, pulp, and paper has skyrocketed. Indonesia became the world's leading producer of palm oil by clearing millions of hectares of dense rainforest and peatland.

Slash-and-burn clearing remains the cheapest method available for land preparation. Hiring crews to manually clear dense jungle growth costs a fortune. Bulldozers require fuel, maintenance, and skilled operators. Striking a match costs nothing.

Smallholders do it because they are poor and desperate for quick yields. Large corporate conglomerates do it because corporate boards care about quarterly margins, and cheap land preparation boosts profit. Even when corporate headquarters claim they have strict zero-burning policies, subsidiaries and independent suppliers often ignore the rules because enforcement in remote jungle provinces has historically been weak.

The financial incentives heavily favor burning. Fines for illegal burning often cost corporations less than the legal alternative of mechanical clearing. When breaking the law is cheaper than following it, bad behavior becomes standard operating procedure.

Blaming the weather isn't an excuse

Indonesian officials love to point the finger at climate patterns when the smoke gets too thick to ignore. El Niño events bring prolonged droughts, turning normal forests into powder kegs.

Drought makes the environment vulnerable, sure. But dry weather doesn't start fires. People do.

Climate change acts as an amplifier, not the root cause. When dry spells hit regions rich with drained peatlands, the vulnerability skyrockets. Yet the government spent years minimizing the crisis, downplaying cross-border haze complaints from neighboring countries, and treating the disaster as an unfortunate act of nature rather than a man-made regulatory failure.

Pressure from neighbors like Singapore finally forced Jakarta to change its tune. Singapore passed extraterritorial laws allowing authorities to fine companies operating abroad if their fires caused toxic pollution within city limits. That financial threat caught the attention of corporate boards in a way that environmental speeches never could.

What a real fix looks like

Fixing this crisis requires dismantling the economic incentives that make burning profitable.

First, Indonesia must aggressively enforce land moratoriums and punish corporate executives, not just low-level farmers. When corporate directors face criminal negligence charges and massive asset seizures for illegal burning on their concessions, behavior changes overnight.

Second, massive ecological restoration must continue. Peatland restoration agencies are actively working to block drainage canals, re-flood dried swamps, and replant native vegetation. Wet peat does not burn. Reviving the water table is the only permanent solution to the subterranean fire problem.

Third, supply chain transparency needs real teeth. Global consumer brands must verify that their palm oil does not come from deforested or burned land. Blockchain tracking and satellite monitoring make it harder for bad actors to launder illegally cleared commodities into international markets, but enforcement gaps remain wide.

The regional haze is not an unpredictable act of God. It is a predictable industrial fallout caused by cheap shortcuts and weak governance. Until the cost of burning outweighs the profit of destruction, the skies across Southeast Asia will keep turning orange every dry season.

DR

Daniel Reed

Drawing on years of industry experience, Daniel Reed provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.