Why Giorgia Meloni and Brothers of Italy Actually Lasted

Why Giorgia Meloni and Brothers of Italy Actually Lasted

Most analysts expected Giorgia Meloni's government to blow up within a year. Italian cabinets usually do. Yet here she stands, leading Brothers of Italy through a historic run that has already passed the longevity mark of postwar Italian governments.

How did a party pulling barely 2% in 2013 climb to 26% in 2022 and stay glued together this long? It wasn't luck, and it wasn't just charismatic speeches at rallies. It came down to a long, calculated partnership between a Roman street-fighter politician and a tight-knit political machine that knew how to wait out every rival on the Italian right. Recently making headlines in this space: Why The Story About Trump Stopping An Israeli Strike On Iran Is Completely Backward.

How Giorgia Meloni Built Brothers of Italy From Scratch

When people talk about the rise of Brothers of Italy, they often treat it like an overnight sensation. Honestly, that misses the grind.

Meloni cofounded the party in December 2012 alongside Ignazio La Russa and Guido Crosetto after breaking away from Silvio Berlusconi's People of Freedom (PdL) coalition. In the 2013 general election, the new party scraped together roughly 2% of the vote and nine seats in the Chamber of Deputies. Not exactly a coronation. Additional insights regarding the matter are detailed by NPR.

What kept the project alive was discipline in the wilderness. While Mario Draghi led a broad national unity government in 2021 and 2022, Brothers of Italy was the only major party in Parliament sitting squarely in opposition. Every time voters got tired of technocrats, grand coalitions, or shifting alliances, there was one clear alternative standing outside the room.

Looking closely at the party's arc, three things made the difference:

  • Staying in opposition when everyone else compromised: Refusing to join Draghi's cabinet gave Meloni a monopoly on anti-establishment frustration on the right.
  • Holding the coalition together without burning bridges: Even when Matteo Salvini's League polled ahead of her in earlier years, Meloni kept her eye on consolidating the center-right rather than starting a civil war.
  • Wrapping hard-edged nationalism in mainstream competence: Once in office, she paired tough talk on borders and national sovereignty with reassuring signals to markets and European partners.

That combination turned a small faction into the dominant force of the right. By September 2022, Brothers of Italy didn't just win its coalition; it became the single biggest vote-getter in Italy.

The Post-Fascist Roots Nobody Can Ignore

You can't understand the bond between Meloni and Brothers of Italy without looking at where both came from. Pretending those roots don't exist is lazy history.

Meloni joined the youth wing of the Italian Social Movement (MSI) at age 15—a party founded after World War II by former fascists. Later came the National Alliance (AN), which tried to modernize the post-fascist right in the 1990s before folding into Berlusconi's project. When Brothers of Italy launched, it even kept the tricolor flame emblem associated with that lineage, authorized through the National Alliance Foundation.

For critics, historians, and anti-fascist groups in Italy, that symbol is a red line. Critics argue the party's rhetoric around "national identity," "natural family," and opposition to what it calls "gender ideology" echoes older authoritarian reflexes. Supporters and party leaders counter that the party stands firmly within democratic institutions, condemns historical fascism, and represents mainstream national conservatism.

Both realities coexist in Italian politics. Watching how Meloni navigates them shows how carefully she calibrates her message: fiery at domestic or ideological rallies, measured and pragmatic when sitting across from foreign leaders or credit rating agencies.

Why This Partnership Survived Where Others Fractured

Italian politics has a graveyard full of ambitious parties that imploded the moment power got real. Why hasn't this one?

Part of the answer is shared history. Figures like La Russa and Crosetto aren't random political mercenaries who showed up for a cabinet seat; they belong to an overlapping ecosystem of the Italian right that has weathered decades of realignment. When pressure hits—whether over budget debates, EU rules, or coalition friction with Forza Italia and the League—longstanding personal and political ties matter.

Another part is pragmatism. Campaign slogans don't always survive contact with governing. Take migration: Brothers of Italy campaigned hard on strict border control and curbing mass migration, yet Meloni's government also moved to expand legal entry quotas for non-EU workers to address labor shortages. To purists, that looks like a compromise. To a seasoned leader trying to keep an economy running and a coalition intact, it's survival.

Political scientists like Salvatore Vassallo and Rinaldo Vignati have examined how third-generation leaders on the Italian right reshaped the movement's appeal over a single parliamentary cycle. The lesson isn't that ideology vanished. Rather, ideology was packaged inside a disciplined party structure that learned when to push and when to bend.

Common Misconceptions About Meloni and Brothers of Italy

A lot of coverage outside Italy gets the basic mechanics backwards. Here are a few myths worth clearing up:

  • Myth: She won an outright parliamentary majority on her own. Actually, Brothers of Italy took about 26% of the vote in 2022, and the wider center-right coalition won around 44%, benefiting from Italy's electoral rules to secure majorities in both chambers.
  • Myth: Her rise was purely a sudden populist wave. Support climbed steadily over years—from single digits and 4.4% in 2018 to 6.4% in the 2019 European elections and 26% in 2022.
  • Myth: Longevity automatically equals unchecked power. Leading a coalition in Rome means constantly managing rival partners, European fiscal constraints, and shifting public mood, even after surpassing postwar cabinet duration records.

How to Follow Italian Politics Without Getting Played by Headlines

If you want to track what happens next with Meloni and Brothers of Italy, skip the hot takes for a minute and look at concrete indicators.

Start with regional and European elections, which act as an early warning system for coalition momentum. Watch budget negotiations and credit ratings, since fiscal credibility in Rome shapes everything from borrowing costs to political leverage. Pay attention to coalition friction with allies like Forza Italia and the League, because the biggest threats to an Italian prime minister usually come from inside the tent rather than across the aisle.

Read primary reporting from outlets like AP News and reference overviews like Encyclopaedia Britannica alongside Italian political analysis. Above all, separate the speeches from the policy decrees—that's where the real story of Brothers of Italy is written every week.

KK

Kenji Kelly

Kenji Kelly has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.