Why Blaming the CRTC Fee Ban for Rogers Slumping Revenue Misses the Real Threat

Why Blaming the CRTC Fee Ban for Rogers Slumping Revenue Misses the Real Threat

The CRTC fee ban did not sink Rogers' wireless revenue. Competitive pressure and sluggish customer growth did.

Read the standard coverage of Rogers Communications' Q3 2026 earnings and you get a neat little story: the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) banned activation, plan-change, and non-device cancellation fees under Telecom Regulatory Policy CRTC 2026-43, Rogers took a hit to wireless service revenue and mobile average revenue per user (ARPU), and now executives are scrambling to recover "real costs".

That framing is lazy. Worse, it lets the carrier off the hook for structural problems that have nothing to do with a setup charge.

When CFO Glenn Brandt told analysts on the Q3 call that setup fees existed to cover real account-onboarding and change costs—and that the fee disappeared while the costs remained—he gave analysts an easy headline. Financial reporters dutifully ran with it. "Rogers seeks to offset cost of CRTC fee ban" sounds urgent. It sounds regulatory. It obscures the bigger picture.

The Lazy Consensus Around Telecom Fee Bans

Here is the conventional wisdom circulating after Q3 2026: regulators outlawed nickel-and-dime charges, carriers lost easy margin, and consumers will simply pay for those costs somewhere else on their bills.

There are two flaws in that consensus.

First, treat "activation cost" with precision. In telecommunications accounting and retail operations, provisioning a SIM card or digital eSIM on an automated backend does not cost tens of dollars per line the way dispatching a field technician to string fiber or coax does. Much of what carriers called an "activation fee" or "connection fee" functioned as pure margin or a switching friction tax—a toll booth on the way in or out. Calling it a direct cost-recovery mechanism confuses variable retail overhead with fixed network and customer-acquisition economics.

Second, look at the numbers in Rogers' Q3 2026 report:

  • Total revenue rose 2% to $5.44 billion.
  • Adjusted EBITDA rose 1% to $2.54 billion, alongside record free cash flow.
  • Wireless service revenue dipped 1%, while mobile ARPU fell 2.6% to $55.22 amid fierce competition and the fee ban.
  • Retail internet net additions slowed to 10,000, down from 29,000 a year earlier, while TV subscribers fell by 35,000.

A 1% dip in wireless service revenue is a speed bump, not a structural collapse. The sharper warning signs sit in slowing net additions, softer pricing power (ARPU), and cord-cutting. Blaming the entire revenue squeeze on banned fees is a convenient narrative shield when rivals are fighting harder for every subscriber.

What the Competitor Coverage Misses About Switching Economics

Most articles treat CRTC 2026-43 as an isolated fee wipeout. It is not. It is part of a broader regulatory push aimed at lowering switching friction across wireless and internet—alongside rules on customer notifications, self-service cancellation mandates, and internet shopping rules.

The Commission's stated goal is straightforward: if leaving or changing plans is penalized, carriers face less pressure to compete aggressively on monthly price and service quality.

Yet the coverage routinely misses the carve-outs and loopholes that determine where revenue actually moves:

  • Device balances still apply: The wireless early-cancellation ban targets plans without a subsidized device; remaining balances owed on subsidized or financed phones still come due when a customer leaves.
  • Internet contracts differ from wireless: The wireless early-cancellation rule amended the Wireless Code, not identically the Internet Code, and device rental plans or broadcasting/TV distribution services sit under separate rules or ongoing proceedings.
  • Ancillary charges shift, not vanish: When one visible fee gets banned, operators look for permissible ways to recover money—through base plan pricing, shipping or handling rules (which have already bounced back and forth in promos and policy tweaks), bundles, or media/sports monetization.

Imagine a scenario where a carrier waives an $70 activation fee on paper, keeps promotional discounts tight, and raises base monthly rates by $3 a month across millions of lines. Over a two-year horizon, the subscriber pays more—not less—even though the line item labeled "activation fee" is gone. Regulators can ban a specific toll, but they cannot repeal basic pricing mechanics in an oligopoly without driving genuine price competition.

Battle Scars From Chasing "Junk" Margin

I have watched telecom and subscription operators spend millions building billing workarounds, agent scripts, and retention waivers to defend low-trust fees that customers despise. Every time an operator tacks on a surprise fee at checkout or a modification charge when a customer calls in to adjust a plan, it burns goodwill for dollars that look tiny next to lifetime customer value.

In high-churn or saturated markets, defending an unpopular ancillary fee is often penny-wise and pound-foolish. You win a few dollars upfront and hand competitors a megaphone every time a customer complains about hidden charges.

At the same time, let's be honest about the downside of this contrarian view: carriers do have real administrative, fulfillment, fraud-screening, and support costs when accounts are opened, modified, or churned. When a regulator strips away a dedicated fee overnight while costs are baked into call centers, logistics, and IT systems, the CFO has to reallocate those dollars somewhere. Ignoring real operating costs is just as naive as pretending a $70 activation charge is pure charity.

Industry observers—from telecom analysts tracking Canadian ARPU trends to regulatory watchers following CRTC proceedings and consumer complaints through the Commission for Complaints for Telecom-television Services (CCTS)—know the real battleground isn't a single setup charge. It is net adds, churn, and base-plan ARPU in a market where growth is harder to buy.

Answering the Questions People Actually Search

Does banning activation and cancellation fees actually lower your monthly phone bill?

Not automatically. It lowers upfront and exit friction, making it easier to switch carriers or change plans without paying an immediate penalty. Whether your monthly bill drops depends on whether competitors cut advertised monthly rates to win your business—or whether carriers quietly adjust plan prices and promotions to make up the difference.

Is Rogers right that "the costs don't disappear" when fees are banned?

The operating costs of running support centers, shipping hardware, and maintaining billing systems do not vanish on the day a rule takes effect. What disappears is the right to bill that specific surcharge as a separate activation or change fee. Treating every banned fee as a 1-to-1 loss of true cost recovery overstates the case, because fees historically included profit margin alongside administrative expense.

What should consumers and operators actually watch next?

Watch promotional structure, base-plan pricing, and switching behavior, not just headline fee bans. Pay close attention to device financing terms (since owing money on a phone still ties you to a contract payoff), watch how carriers bundle wireless with internet and media/sports assets, and keep every receipt if a prohibited fee ever slips onto a statement.

Unconventional Moves That Actually Work

If you are an operator trying to replace banned fee revenue without triggering regulatory backlash or customer revolt, stop hunting for sneaky new surcharges. Fix the unit economics instead:

  1. Automate self-service changes so costs actually drop. If modification fees are gone, make plan changes and upgrades effortless in the app so human agents aren't burning expensive minutes on routine tweaks.
  2. Compete cleanly on transparent monthly value. Lower friction means customers can leave faster if they feel gouged. Keep base pricing legible and earn retention through network reliability and straightforward perks rather than gotcha charges.
  3. Separate hardware financing from service pricing. Be crystal clear about what is owed on a device versus what the monthly service plan costs. Clarity reduces billing disputes, CCTS escalations, and support drag.

And if you are a customer, stop celebrating a banned setup fee and start shopping your recurring monthly bill. The real money has always been in the monthly rate, not the toll booth at the door.

KK

Kenji Kelly

Kenji Kelly has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.